Wednesday, July 16, 2008

Mobile Broadband Services: HSPA Vs. WiMAX

Spectrum Analysis
• the average 3G spectrum cost/Hz is higher than the average WiMAX spectrum cost/Hz.
• WIMAX spectrum is more economical (because the total 3G spectrum is in lower frequency bands than the total WIMAX spectrum)
• WiMAX base stations can connect to each other even when they are not in the line-of-sight.

Users
• two technologies are close substitutes; both are enabling same types of services for the same devices
and contexts. Differences in the technological performance are also considered to be quite small.
• in case of HSDPA , all users will just have lower data rates, while the load on a WiMAX router in a similar
situation goes up, and it may fail to cope with it.
• Both technologies have practically the same capacities for transmitting multimedia data. Both WiMAX
and HSDPA have QoS and traffic prioritizing.

Technical and Standard
HSPA WiMAX

Dublix method FDD TDD
Multiple access CDMA OFDMA
Channel Bandwidth 2x ( 5MHz ) 10MHz (scalable)
Modulation QPSK QPSK, 16 QAM and 64 QAM
Bit rate up to 14.4 Mbps up to 40Mbps

No comments: